The #1 Squat Exercise MISTAKE That We’re Being Taught To Do

Most of the textbook guidelines we’re taught for performing the squat exercise are pretty similar

Keep the upper back straight, keep the feet about shoulder width apart, bend at the hips and knees, etc..

But, there’s another guideline that’s taught by most textbooks and even health & fitness professionals but it can be the #1 squat exercise mistake in those who suffer from nagging lower body injuries

It’s something that isn’t particularly obvious either…

It has nothing to do with the upper back, bar placement nor the hips…

…It is assuming squat position with the toes pointed out

While this may not be problematic for apparently healthy individuals, it can have a few drawbacks for those dealing with lower back, hip, knee or ankle pain:

  • increases stability through leverage but decreases activation of the hip extensors
  • increases activation of the quadriceps, gluteus medius and lumbar extensors
  • results in increased stress to the knees, hips & lumbar spine
  • in more extreme cases, the toes pointed out position can contribute to increased stress to the sacroiliac joints of the pelvis
  • Most functional & athletic movements do not occur from this position

For example: running or jumping with the toes pointed out decreases force production during acceleration, negatively affects deceleration mechanics and develops poor alignment and joint stability of the lower extremities

Most individuals prefer squatting with the toes pointed out because it feels stable and as if the feet are straight

In most cases, if you ask a client who squats this way to point their toes straight ahead they will feel as if they are ‘pigeon-toed’ and will have difficulty keeping the knees and ankles from collapsing inward

Because of this, it’s often assumed that squatting with the toes straight is ‘bad for the knees’…

…But, if we look at it from more of a lower body assessment perspective what we’re REALLY seeing is inefficient hip mechanics…it’s the lack of hip stability that causes the real problems

When the hip extensors and/or abductors are weak the integrity of the lower extremities becomes compromised often resulting in pain or injuries to the hips, knees, ankles or even the lower back

And, although the squat gets a bad rap for causing injuries to the knees and lower back, the reality is that the movement itself is something our bodies are designed to perform…

…it’s one of the first movements we performed as babies learning to stand

Unfortunately, as we get older (and technology advances) we drive, sit at computers, perform desk jobs, watch television and without proper conditioning of the hip musculature function is lost which leads to a growing list of nagging pain and injuries

The squat isn’t a bad movement but a lack of physical conditioning to squat efficiently is

11 Responses to “The #1 Squat Exercise MISTAKE That We’re Being Taught To Do”

  • alexandra demetriouNo Gravatar:

    Good post, and so true! Proper form is key to a long and healthy lifting lifestyle! It is so worth the money to get a qualified person to train you.
    alexandra demetriou, OTR/L CHT
    http://www.signaturehandtherapy.com

  • David ElcoateNo Gravatar:

    Kevin,

    Great post I love the information on the squat technique. Like you say most people have weak hip extensors and poor LPS and are unable to resist the pull of the hip flexors and adductors and therefore the toes turning out prevents the collapse of the kinetic chain.

    Keep up the good posts, I love reading your stuff.

    David
    Personal Trainer Essex

  • Kevin YatesNo Gravatar:

    Thanks for the comment David.

  • MarkSpizerNo Gravatar:

    great post as usual!

  • pharmacy technicianNo Gravatar:

    My cousin recommended this blog and she was totally right keep up the fantastic work!

  • forex robotNo Gravatar:

    found your site on del.icio.us today and really liked it.. i bookmarked it and will be back to check it out some more later

  • SteveNo Gravatar:

    Good post, and so true! Proper form is key to a long and healthy lifting lifestyle! It is so worth the money to get a qualified person to train you.
    alexandra demetriou, OTR/L CHT
    http://www.signaturehandtherapy.com

  • jump manualNo Gravatar:

    I had been doing this kind of exercise. I make sure that I execute this kind of exercise everyday and I’m seeing a good result.

  • Danny NguyenNo Gravatar:

    I did some full squat keeping my feet foward where my upper quad touches my stomach at the bottom, but it also feels as my quads for doing more work than the hamstrings.

    I want to develop more hamstrings/glutes since I have a weak P-chain and stronger quads. I can I engage the hamstrings more in the squat keeping my feet foward on an narrow stance squat?

  • Kevin YatesNo Gravatar:

    I wouldn’t worry about the stance so much. Keep your feet shoulder width apart. Also, if you watched yourself in a mirror from the side during your squatting you may notice your trunk leaning quite a bit forward which decreases the glute/hamstring involvement.

    Practice keeping your trunk more upright (forget about touching your stomach to your quads)while driving your hips back and down. Keep your abdominals and glutes engaged as you descend. This is the most difficult challenge and where most people lose the abs and glute involvement.

    Really focus on the muscles the entire time.

    Try a warm up circuit of exercises to:

    1) activate your abdominal muscles as stabilizers and
    2) activate your glutes/hamstrings

  • [...] LINK:THE NO.1 SQUAT MISTAKE AND WHY ITS BAD This entry was posted in WOD. Bookmark the permalink. ← Friday [...]

Leave a Reply